Wikinomics: How Mass Collaboration Changes Everything (review: 2.5/5)

Wikinomics: How Mass Collaboration Changes Everything was pretty much a disappointment. I wouldn’t go so far as to call it bad. I was just hoping for a less history and a more speculation. Unfortunately, if you’ve been paying a moderate amount of attention to the internet/ social software/ business world for the past few years, you won’t find much new information.
Don Tapscott and Anthony Williams have done a good job of rounding up the big trends, their so-called Principles of Wikinomics: openness, peering, sharing, and acting globally. Much of the work is a sort of biography of these paradigms and the companies & products that embody them. You probably know their names: Linux, Wikipedia, Google, Flickr, IBM, BMW, Best Buy, etc.

Each chapter reviews a new trend, fleshes out the history and summarizes by way of canned, italicized guidelines for business. I wish I hadn’t returned the book to the library already or I’d quote a few. Anyway, they also mix in a few Trendwatching-like neologisms, like “Ideagoras” and “New Alexandrians”. By far the most intriguing part of the book was Chapter 9, discussing the “wiki workplace.” Perhaps that’s because the idea is still the most nebulous and little-tested: “We are shifting from closed and hierarchical workplaces with rigid employment relationships increasingly self-organized, distributed, and collaborative human capital networks that draw knowledge and resources from inside and outside the firm” That’ll be an interesting process to see over the next few years. I think free agent/ consultant/ collaborative culture will become more and more popular.

LilyPond looks like an interesting musical notation program. It relies on ASCII text input, and translates it into high-quality graphical notation, harking back to the professional engravings of yore. This reminds me of the LaTeX markup and typesetting language—you get to focus on your product and stop futzing around so much with the visuals. I’ll have to give it a try. The developers have written an interesting essay about the nuance and perfection that most computer-generated notation lacks, and thus, the inspiration for LilyPond. Typography in music! Sweet!

Paul is going off the Flickr Grid: “My inner geek isn’t completely thrilled with my move to Flickr… Part of me thinks that all of the awesome stuff that Flickr enables (community, conversation, collaboration, cataloging, aggregation, and so much more) should be done in a distributed way across the Web.” He’s doing a great job of documenting the whole techie side of the process.

Down and Out in the Magic Kingdom (review: 5/5)

This book reminded me how much I love science fiction. Down and Out in the Magic Kingdom (which, per Cory Doctorow‘s tradition, you can download for free) takes place in a transhuman future. Poverty, scarcity, and sickness have been pretty much eliminated. Our hapless narrator-hero, Julius, has been killed (again) and his rivals are trying to take over one of his pet projects where he works at Disneyland. He fights back with the help of tenuous friendships and ill-formed plans, and it’s pretty much wonderful the whole way through.
One of the best parts about great science fiction (and I think this one counts) is just taking a few ideas and seeing where they lead, a sort of narrative thought experiment. Luckily Doctorow doesn’t get too explicitly philisophical, but there is some great hypothesis-spinning daydream material here. What if we were all networked, able to be really, individually connected to each and every other person? How does society recalibrate value where material scarcity no longer exists? If you could freeze your life for 500 or 10,000 years and wake up later, well… what would that be like? What’s the effect on human relationships? All this, and more. Go read it.

Umberto Eco’s 1994 essay on the Future of the Book.

Plato was expressing a fear that still survived in his day. Thinking is an internal affair; the real thinker would not allow books to think instead of him. Nowadays, nobody shares these fears, for two very simple reasons. First of all, we know that books are not ways of making somebody else think in our place; on the contrary they are machines that provoke further thoughts.

It reads a bit dated now, but it’s still pretty good.